Something about the AI industry keeps bugging me, and it isn't the technology.
The biggest companies in the industry invest in each other and buy from each other at the same time. Money goes out as an investment and comes back as revenue, after passing through two or three partners. Nvidia puts money into OpenAI.1 OpenAI pays Oracle for computing power. Oracle buys the chips from Nvidia.2 Everyone's numbers go up, and what holds it all together isn't cash anyone has earned yet. It's what they expect to earn, and what everyone says everyone is worth.
AMD is my favorite example, because it's so plain. It gave OpenAI the right to buy its shares for a cent apiece, as long as OpenAI keeps buying its chips.3 The supplier hands the customer a piece of itself so the customer keeps buying. Microsoft, Amazon and Google do versions of the same thing.4 Journalists already have a name for it: circular financing.5
And the numbers don't hide it well. OpenAI told investors it plans to spend about $600 billion on computing by 2030. This year it's reportedly on track to make somewhere around $25 billion, and lose around $14 billion.6
Or look at it from another side. Nvidia, a company that makes chips, is worth more than all the farmland in Australia, and not by a little. That's land that feeds some 75 million people.7 One is where food comes from. The other makes chips. That's how far up the price of everything AI has gone.
Right now, everything is on sale. Tokens are cheap. Pay $20 and, if you use it hard, you can burn through many times that in tokens at API prices. Nobody outside the companies knows exactly what it costs them to serve you. What we do know is that the companies as a whole are losing money, and investors are covering the difference, not you.8
Investors are paying because they were promised AGI. Someone will win the race, the winner takes everything, and the loss is the price of the ticket. But look at who made that promise, and who believed it. People. Not LLMs. The people who are supposed to run the economy heard “AGI” and kept writing checks.
I'm not sure any of this bursts. That's the honest version.
Maybe this is a new steam engine, and this one improves itself. If so, the usual math doesn't apply. Or maybe every new model is just a bit closer to the last one, progress flattens, nobody wins, and the discount ends the day that becomes obvious. I hold both. They point in opposite directions.9
What I do know is what happens to a bubble around a real technology, because it already happened. In the 1840s Britain went crazy for railways. Shares climbed until they collapsed, investors lost their money, and about a third of the planned lines were never built. But the tracks that were built stayed, and they're more than half of Britain's network today.10 The shareholders lost. The tracks stayed.
What makes me angry isn't the technology. I'm not an idiot, I'm not going to argue against progress. What makes me angry is the padding: people dressing up the story around it when they don't even need to, because progress keeps going without it. Sooner or later that comes back to the whole world, the way it did in 2008 with mortgages.11 I'm not saying AI is a mortgage. I'm saying the shape looks the same: something real underneath, a padded story on top, and a bill that reaches people who never signed anything.
It'll be harder to see this time. In 2008 you could point at a house. Now it's frozen hiring, smaller pensions, and a bad few years blamed on “the economy.”12
There's another bill, and it isn't on any balance sheet. We're getting weaker thinkers. When the model does the thinking, you stop practicing it. I said in the first essay that back then you knew every corner of your own project, and that today most people won't, because people are lazy. Someday somebody will have to check the model's work, and they'll never have had to learn how.13
We'll pay for that later, too. Nobody puts that on a slide.
None of this is about the tool. Generative AI is very good, and I use it every day. That has nothing to do with whether OpenAI or Nvidia have their books in order. The companies are building up valuation and investment and feeding people the illusion of profit. The tool is a different story.
The engine works. What I don't know is who pays for it, who owns the track when it's built, and who's left holding the bill if the story turns out to be just a story.
Same field, seen from the money side.